Portfolio Rebalancing: Maintaining Your Target Asset Allocation
Learn how to use rebalancing to keep your investment portfolio aligned with your goals, manage risk, and implement a disciplined investment approach.
Regular rebalancing helps maintain your desired level of investment risk and return potential.
Introduction to Portfolio Rebalancing
Portfolio rebalancing is the process of realigning the weightings of assets in your investment portfolio to maintain your original desired level of asset allocation. Over time, as different investments earn different returns, your portfolio will naturally drift from its target allocation.
Why Portfolios Drift
Portfolio drift occurs because assets grow at different rates. For example, in a bull market, stocks typically outperform bonds, causing the equity portion of a portfolio to become larger than intended. Conversely, during market downturns, the safer fixed-income portion might represent a larger percentage than planned.
Illustration of portfolio drift for a 60/40 stock/bond portfolio over a 5-year period
The Concept of Target Allocation
Your target asset allocation should be based on your:
- Financial goals (retirement, education, home purchase, etc.)
- Investment time horizon
- Risk tolerance
- Current financial situation
Rebalancing ensures your portfolio maintains the risk/return profile appropriate for your situation. For a deeper dive into establishing your initial asset allocation, see our Asset Allocation Strategies guide.
Rebalancing Strategies
There are several approaches to determining when and how to rebalance your portfolio:
Calendar-Based Rebalancing
This time-based approach involves reviewing and potentially adjusting your portfolio at predetermined intervals:
- Monthly: High frequency, but typically incurs excessive transaction costs
- Quarterly: More active approach, suitable for larger portfolios
- Semi-annually: Balanced approach for moderate-sized portfolios
- Annually: Most common and typically sufficient for most investors
Comparing portfolio risk and transaction costs across different rebalancing frequencies
Threshold-Based Rebalancing
This percentage-based approach triggers rebalancing when asset classes drift beyond a predetermined threshold from their target allocations.
Narrow Bands (3-5%)
Keeps portfolio very close to target allocation but may trigger frequent rebalancing and higher costs. Example: Rebalance when any asset class is ±5% from its target.
Wide Bands (10%+)
Reduces transaction costs and tax consequences but allows more significant portfolio drift. Example: Rebalance when any asset class is ±10% from its target.
Rebalancing bands visualization showing when rebalancing would be triggered
Combination Approaches
Many investors use a hybrid strategy that checks at regular intervals (e.g., quarterly or annually) but only rebalances when allocations have drifted beyond specified thresholds. This approach balances the discipline of regular review with cost efficiency.
Benefits of Regular Rebalancing
Regular portfolio rebalancing offers several important benefits:
Risk Control
Perhaps the most significant benefit of rebalancing is maintaining your intended risk level. Without rebalancing, your portfolio could become significantly more aggressive (or conservative) than intended, potentially exposing you to unwanted risk during market downturns.
Volatility comparison between rebalanced and non-rebalanced portfolios during market cycles
Return Optimization
While rebalancing may sometimes reduce returns during strong bull markets, research suggests it can enhance risk-adjusted returns over complete market cycles. By systematically selling assets that have increased in price and buying those that have decreased, rebalancing enforces a disciplined "buy low, sell high" approach.
Behavioral Benefits
One of the most overlooked advantages of rebalancing is how it removes emotion from the investment process. Regular rebalancing provides discipline, preventing investors from:
- Chasing performance by increasing allocation to recent winners
- Panic selling during market downturns
- Holding too much cash out of fear or indecision
Research Insight:
Vanguard research suggests that over long periods, portfolios that are regularly rebalanced typically experience about 20% less volatility than portfolios that are never rebalanced, while maintaining comparable returns.
Implementation Methods
There are several ways to execute portfolio rebalancing:
Rebalancing with Cash Flows
One of the most tax-efficient and low-cost rebalancing strategies uses cash flows to gradually realign your portfolio:
- New contributions: Direct new investment contributions to underweight asset classes
- Dividend and interest reinvestment: Direct income from overweight assets to purchase underweight assets
- Withdrawals: Take planned withdrawals from overweight assets
This approach is particularly effective for portfolios with regular contributions or withdrawals and helps minimize transactions costs and tax consequences.
Buying and Selling
When cash flows are insufficient to rebalance the portfolio effectively, you may need to sell overweight assets and use the proceeds to purchase underweight assets. This approach requires careful consideration of transaction costs and potential tax implications.
Comparison of different rebalancing implementation methods
Using Rebalancing Bands
Rebalancing bands (or corridors) establish acceptable ranges around target allocations. They help strike a balance between maintaining your desired allocation and minimizing transaction costs.
| Asset Class | Target Allocation | ±5% Band | Action Required When |
|---|---|---|---|
| US Stocks | 40% | 35-45% | <35% (buy) or >45% (sell) |
| International Stocks | 20% | 15-25% | <15% (buy) or >25% (sell) |
| Bonds | 30% | 25-35% | <25% (buy) or >35% (sell) |
| Cash/Alternatives | 10% | 5-15% | <5% (buy) or >15% (sell) |
Tax Considerations
In taxable accounts, rebalancing can trigger capital gains taxes. Several strategies can help minimize the tax impact:
Tax impact comparison of different rebalancing approaches
Tax-Efficient Rebalancing Strategies
- Rebalance within tax-advantaged accounts (IRAs, 401(k)s) where selling doesn't trigger capital gains taxes
- Use new contributions strategically in taxable accounts rather than selling positions
- Tax-loss harvesting to offset gains from necessary sales
- Consider asset location by holding tax-inefficient investments in tax-advantaged accounts
- Charitable donations of appreciated securities from overweight asset classes
- Select specific lots when selling using tax-lot selection methods like specific identification rather than first-in-first-out
Practical Rebalancing Workflow
Following a systematic process makes rebalancing more efficient and effective:
Step-by-Step Rebalancing Process
- Review your target allocation - Confirm your target asset allocation still aligns with your goals and risk tolerance
- Calculate current allocation - Determine the current percentage of each asset class in your portfolio
- Compare to targets - Identify which asset classes are outside their target ranges
- Determine rebalancing needs - Calculate the amount (in dollars) that needs to be shifted between asset classes
- Consider tax implications - Select the most tax-efficient approach to implement the rebalancing
- Execute trades - Make the necessary transactions
- Document the rebalancing - Record when and how you rebalanced for future reference
Rebalancing Tools and Resources
Several tools can help streamline the rebalancing process:
- Portfolio management software - Tools like Personal Capital, Morningstar Portfolio Manager, or brokerage-provided portfolio analysis tools
- Spreadsheets - Custom spreadsheets can help track allocation and calculate rebalancing needs
- Automatic rebalancing services - Some robo-advisors and managed account services offer automatic rebalancing
- Target-date and balanced funds - These funds perform internal rebalancing automatically
Common Rebalancing Pitfalls to Avoid
- Rebalancing too frequently - Excessive rebalancing increases costs without significant benefits
- Ignoring tax consequences - Failing to consider the tax impact of rebalancing in taxable accounts
- Emotional decision-making - Letting market predictions or emotions override your systematic rebalancing plan
- Forgetting to reassess target allocation - As your life circumstances change, your target allocation may need adjustment
- Neglecting asset location - Not considering which accounts (taxable vs. tax-advantaged) to rebalance in
Frequently Asked Questions About Portfolio Rebalancing
What is portfolio rebalancing and why is it important?
Portfolio rebalancing is the process of realigning the weightings of assets in an investment portfolio to maintain your original desired level of asset allocation and risk. Over time, as different investments earn different returns, your portfolio's asset allocation will drift from its original target. Rebalancing brings your portfolio back to its intended asset mix.
It's important because it helps manage risk, enforces investment discipline by encouraging you to 'buy low and sell high,' and ensures your portfolio remains aligned with your financial goals and risk tolerance. Without regular rebalancing, your portfolio could become more aggressive or conservative than intended, potentially exposing you to unwanted risk or insufficient growth potential.
How often should I rebalance my portfolio?
There are several approaches to determining rebalancing frequency:
- Calendar-based rebalancing involves reviewing your portfolio at regular intervals (monthly, quarterly, semi-annually, or annually). Annual rebalancing is most common and typically sufficient for most investors.
- Threshold-based rebalancing triggers rebalancing when any asset class drifts beyond a predetermined percentage (typically 5-10%) from its target allocation.
- A combination approach checks at regular intervals but only rebalances when allocation thresholds are exceeded.
Research suggests that annual or semi-annual rebalancing with 5% threshold bands offers a good balance between maintaining proper asset allocation and minimizing transaction costs and tax consequences. Your optimal frequency should account for your portfolio size, trading costs, tax situation, and personal preferences.
What are the most tax-efficient ways to rebalance a portfolio?
Tax-efficient rebalancing strategies include:
- Rebalancing within tax-advantaged accounts (IRAs, 401(k)s) where selling doesn't trigger capital gains taxes
- Using new contributions to purchase underweight assets rather than selling overweight positions
- Directing dividends, interest, and capital gain distributions from overweight assets to underweight ones
- Utilizing tax-loss harvesting to offset gains from necessary sales of appreciated assets
- Making charitable donations with appreciated securities from overweight asset classes
- Considering asset location by holding tax-inefficient investments in tax-advantaged accounts while keeping tax-efficient investments in taxable accounts
- Being strategic about which specific lots to sell when reducing positions (such as using specific identification of shares rather than first-in-first-out)
Working with a tax professional can help optimize your rebalancing strategy for your specific tax situation.
Does rebalancing improve investment returns?
Rebalancing primarily serves as a risk management technique rather than a return enhancement strategy. Research on whether rebalancing improves absolute returns is mixed and often depends on market conditions.
During periods of strong positive trends in high-risk assets (like extended bull markets), rebalancing may slightly reduce absolute returns by shifting money away from top-performing assets. However, in volatile or cyclical markets, rebalancing typically improves risk-adjusted returns by reducing portfolio volatility while maintaining comparable returns.
The most significant benefit of rebalancing is maintaining a consistent risk profile aligned with your investment goals. By forcing you to systematically sell high and buy low, rebalancing provides discipline that can help avoid emotional decision-making and potentially capture reversion-to-mean effects in asset classes.
When evaluating rebalancing benefits, focus on risk-adjusted returns (Sharpe ratio) rather than absolute returns alone.
Related Articles
Asset Allocation Strategies
Learn how to distribute your investments across different asset classes based on your risk tolerance and goals.
Risk Management Techniques
Understand different types of investment risk and strategies to manage them effectively.
Diversification Principles
Explore how diversification can reduce risk and improve the stability of your investment portfolio.
Tax-Efficient Investing
Strategies to minimize tax impact and maximize after-tax returns on your investments.
Optimize Your Investment Strategy
Use our free dividend calculator to help analyze potential returns for dividend-paying investments in your portfolio.
Try Our Dividend Calculator